FhSim  3.1.0
Marine systems simulation
Loading...
Searching...
No Matches
0462 — Net panels take no wave inertia force (screen added mass, Froude-Krylov)
ID 0462
Class KNOWN-LIMITATION
Severity 2
Status blocked

Models: Net/NetStructure

Found: 2026-11-18, plan HP wave 3, case B9 of fhsim_validation

Decision needed: the owner rules whether net panels get an inertia term (screen added mass) and how.

Evidence

src/net/NetFlowInteraction.cpp:36-48 (FlowAt) gives a panel the flow velocity only: the current and the wake, plus the wave particle velocity averaged over the nodes. No wave acceleration reaches the panel law. Cable elements do get wave excitation: src/net/NetCableElement.cpp:239 calls AddWaveExcitation (lines 603-628) and src/net/NetStructure.cpp:647-651 takes its Jacobian with MeanWaveAcceleration.

Case B9 of fhsim_validation (Balash 2009, 1 m x 1 m net samples in regular waves, force amplitude, tracked):

  • 0 of 12 rows pass in all three panel laws (local_through_flow, screen_kf2012, screen_mf2022). The model is 62 to 89 % low.
  • The deep-water wave of the environment has a lower depth-averaged velocity over the net than the tank wave (MENV-0089). The finite-depth factor on the force is only 1.6 to 3.6. After that correction the rows are still 8 to 78 % low.
  • Inertia on the twine volume (Froude-Krylov plus Ca = 1) is about 0.5 N. It does not close the gap.
  • Balash Fig. 14 gives an effective thickness of 0.01 to 0.07 m for the inertia part of the force. That is a screen-level added mass, much larger than the twine volume.

Effect

A net panel in waves has too little force at low KC. Nets in waves (cages, screens, sample tests) are under-loaded. In current only, nothing changes.

Possible fix

  • Add an inertia term to the panel force: the screen added mass with the effective thickness of Balash Fig. 14, times the wave acceleration. This needs a thickness law (as a function of solidity or KC) and a ruling.
  • Add Froude-Krylov force on the twine volume only. This is simple but too small (about 0.5 N in B9).
  • Leave it and record the gap as a model limit in the validation report.

Test that would prove it

Case B9 of fhsim_validation (cases/hydrodynamics/net_panel_load/B9_balash2009_net_in_waves) rows pass their bands, after MENV-0089 or with the finite-depth wave velocity.

Risk

The term changes every net result in waves. Cases in current only stay as they are. The thickness law is fitted to one paper, so it may not hold for other nets. Report any moves in moves.md.