FhSim  3.1.0
Marine systems simulation
Loading...
Searching...
No Matches
0463 — Test/FlowProbe has a fixed position and cannot follow a net node
ID 0463
Class API
Severity 1
Status ready

Models: —

Found: 2026-11-18, plan HP wave 4 review, validation case D5b (fhsim_validation)

Decision needed: none. This is a test object. The owner may rule the input form (a node position port, or a node index into one net).

Evidence

tests/objects/FlowProbe.cpp:12 reads the parameter Position once into m_position. FlowProbe.cpp:28-38 evaluates GetParticleVelocity and GetWakeDeficit at that fixed point. The object has no input port (FlowProbe.cpp:13-14 adds only the output ports Velocity and WakeDeficit), so the point cannot follow a net node. The header is tests/objects/FlowProbe.h.

D5b (fhsim_validation, cases/hydrodynamics/net_wake/D5b_foere2016_wake_behind_cage/NOTES.md) compares the flow speed 0.20 m behind the net with Moe-Føre 2016 Fig. 8. The paper moved its propeller log with the deformed net side. D5b puts the probe at x = 1.075 m, the undeformed rear face plus 0.20 m.

Effect

A validation case cannot place a probe a fixed distance behind the deformed rear net. At the load the net side swings downstream, so the probe may be closer to the net than 0.20 m, or inside the cage.

Possible fix

Add input ports to Test/FlowProbe: a reference position (3) and an offset parameter (3), so the point is reference + offset. A net node position port feeds the reference. The Position parameter stays as the default, so the existing decks do not change.

Test that would prove it

A deck with a Test/FlowProbe wired to a Net/NetStructure node and an offset of 0.20 m. The reported point moves with the node. Then D5b uses it.

Risk

A test object only, never in the shipped library. It does not move any result as long as the Position default stays.