FhSim  3.1.0
Marine systems simulation
Loading...
Searching...
No Matches
0461 — Lader 2005 net cage with weights: drag high, lift low (D3a, D3c)
ID 0461
Class KNOWN-LIMITATION
Severity 2
Status blocked

Models: Net/NetStructure

Found: 2026-11-18, plan HP wave 2

Decision needed: the owner chooses whether to investigate or to record this as a model limit. The first step would be to compare the deformed shape, with case D3b (Fig. 6) or a node-position output.

Evidence

Cases D3a and D3c of fhsim_validation (cases/hydrodynamics/net_cage_load/D3a_lader2005_drag, D3c_lader2005_lift, tracked), Lader and Enerhaug 2005.

  • D3a drag: 5 of 15 rows pass, median error +7.7 %. By weight mode: WM1 +4 %, WM2 +13 %, WM3 +20 %. The ratio drag/U² is 1.07, 1.16 and 1.16 times the measured value.
  • D3c lift: 1 of 12 rows pass, median error -35 %. At 0.5 m/s the ratio lift/drag is 0.16 in the model and 0.40 measured. For WM3 the lift is 17 N against 34 to 37 N measured.

Reading: the model cage deforms too little. The sides stay too upright, which gives more drag and less lift (the sin 2 alpha argument of Lader and Enerhaug 2005, p. 83).

The panel law alone is unlikely to be the cause: B1b passes 8 of 8 rows and B6a 20 of 24.

Missing drag on the weights is about 0.4 N each against a weight of 6.8 N. That tilts the lines by about 3 degrees, which is too small.

Suspects (unverified): BarE 4e6 (a provisional input), the 6-section mesh and the wake factor.

Effect

Net cages with bottom weights in current give too much drag and too little lift. Weights and deformation of cages are affected.

Possible fix

  • Compare the deformed shape first: case D3b from Fig. 6 or a node-position output.
  • Then test the suspects one by one: BarE, the mesh resolution, the wake factor.
  • Or record the gap as a model limit in the validation report.

Test that would prove it

The D3a and D3c rows pass their bands (fhsim_validation, cases net_cage_load D3a and D3c).

Risk

A change of the net stiffness or the wake factor moves other net results (B1b, B6a, D4a). Report the moves in moves.md.