FhSim  3.1.0
Marine systems simulation
Loading...
Searching...
No Matches
0458 — C3b wake ratio misses through its reference denominator, not the wake strength
ID 0458
Class KNOWN-LIMITATION
Severity 2
Status blocked

Models: —

Found: 2026-11-16, validation case C3b (fhsim_validation, plan HV2 task T1)

Decision needed: Owner: accept the gap, or choose how to treat the reference denominator (Zhan's planar wake-off prediction rc_planar_N).

Evidence

Case C3b, variant wake_on, output ratio (drag with the wake over drag without it, both minus still water), source zhan2006 (Table 7 over the Fig. 8 prediction without energy loss), tolerance 10 % relative. Reference run fhsim_validation/results/reference/validation_results_tracked.json. All 9 rows miss, all with the simulated ratio too high:

Net s Speed (m/s) Measured Simulated Error
0.223 0.50 0.7313 0.8598 +0.1758
0.223 0.75 0.722 0.8637 +0.1961
0.223 1.00 0.7055 0.8615 +0.2212
0.128 0.50 0.7652 0.912 +0.1918
0.128 0.75 0.8204 0.9194 +0.1207
0.128 1.00 0.8102 0.9231 +0.1393
0.215 0.50 0.6907 0.844 +0.2221
0.215 0.75 0.6587 0.8573 +0.3015
0.215 1.00 0.6529 0.8645 +0.3242

Zhan's drag is 18 to 35 % below the planar-derived prediction. The model wake lowers the drag by 8 to 16 %.

Old tags: MENV-0007 (resolved 2026-09-28, wake kernel at high solidity, W2 and W10, disclose only), MARE-0111 (resolved 2026-09-27, in-plane load of the screen laws) and MARE-0131 (resolved 2026-10-20, angle form). None of them covers this ratio. MENV-0007 is about the kernel against MF2022 and KF2012, not a cylinder drag against Zhan.

Re-scope (owner 2026-11-17, C1 wake analysis)

The first reading of this issue blamed the wake strength. The C1 wake analysis changed that. The C3b miss sits mostly in the denominator of the ratio: Zhan's planar wake-off prediction rc_planar_N against the load laws without wake. The model's wake-off drag is 0.73 to 0.90 of that prediction. The wake strength is not the main cause. Case C3a passes 9 of 9 rows at -12 % to +8 %.

The table above and the old tags still hold. The text "the model wake lowers the drag by 8 to 16 %" is a fact of the run, but it no longer points to the wake kernel. The check in "Possible fix" about the kernel strength and the wake coupling is dropped. The check about the measurement (frame and blockage) stays, now for the denominator.

Effect

A cylindrical net behind its own wake carries more drag than Zhan measured. The error grows with solidity.

Possible fix

Compare the wake-off drag of the load laws with rc_planar_N per net and speed, and decide whether the laws or the reference are off. Needs an owner ruling.

Test that would prove it

Case C3b in fhsim_validation has no row outside 10 %, or the owner records the gap as accepted.

Risk

A change of a load law without wake moves every net result. A change of the wake coupling is no longer proposed here.