FhSim  3.1.0
Marine systems simulation
Loading...
Searching...
No Matches
0141 — Trawl/CenterWeight drag coefficient is a constant, not a function of Re
ID 0141
Class KNOWN-LIMITATION
Severity 2
Status blocked

Models: Trawl/CenterWeight

Found: 2026-11-18, validation case A1 (fhsim_validation, cases/hydrodynamics/body_added_mass/A1_sphere_settling_speed)

Decision needed: the owner chooses whether the center weight gets a Reynolds-number dependent drag coefficient (for example a Morrison 2013 type correlation), or keeps the constant and documents the Re range in which it is valid. The same question is open for Net/Sphere (MARE-0460), which shares the sphere law.

Evidence

DragCoefficient defaults to the environment's sphere default, 0.5 (fhsim_environment/include/fhsim_environment/hydrodynamics/SphereHydro.h:47: double cd = 0.5;). src/trawl/CenterWeight.h:100: "Drag coefficient C_d of the sphere on its frontal area π r² [-], >= 0. (Default: the environment's sphere default, 0.5)". The law has no Re input.

Case A1 (tracked, tolerance 5 %) compares the terminal settling speed with the Morrison 2013 C_D(Re) correlation, which ranges from 0.39 to 1.04 over the eight rows. Reference run (fhsim_validation/results/reference/validation_results_tracked.json, variant fishery_center_weight): 1 of 8 rows pass. Settling speed error is +0.441 at Re 100, median -0.082, minimum -0.114.

Effect

At low Re the weight settles too fast. At high Re it settles 8 to 11 % too slowly.

Possible fix

  1. Add a Re-dependent C_D to the sphere law in fhsim_environment, used by this model.
  2. Keep the constant and state its valid Re range in the model documentation and in case A1.

Test that would prove it

Case A1, variant fishery_center_weight: all eight rows pass at 5 %.

Risk

Option 1 moves the results of trawl systems with a center weight, so regression baselines (tests/in/CenterWeight) move and need an owner ruling.