Rudi et al. (1988) towed panels as KF2012 Fig. 5 plots them (angle dependence, L5): a fit check, the data the angle harmonics were fitted to. The comparisons with measurements that the law was not fitted to (Zhan L8, Løland L6) are the cases B5a, B5b and B6b of the validation battery (repo fhsim_validation).
Known misfit, disclosed by owner decision (2026-09-27; lift revised by the ruling of 2026-10-13, MARE-0110; drag angle form revised by the ruling of 2026-10-20, ENV-0120; lift angle form by the ruling of 2026-10-21, ENV-0125). The default law LocalThroughFlow takes its lift from the MF2022 Eq. 10 lift-to-drag ratio and agrees with MF2022 at 0° and 45°. Its drag angle form is option O1 of the ENV-0120 prototype, a3 = 0.017 and a5 = 0.053 (a3 + a5 = 0.07 keeps 0° and 45°); it still misses Rudi and Zhan at 30–80° by 0.002–0.006 in four rows (about Rudi's digitising error, accepted by the owner; ENV-0120 is resolved). The lift angle form follows Rudi with a sixth harmonic pinned at 45°, b4 = 0.092 and b6 = 0.105 (ENV-0125, resolved); three Rudi rows still fail (Sn 0.144 at 80°, Sn 0.317 at 60° and 80°), and Løland's pure sin 2θ is not followed. Zhan's speed trend is put down to frame deformation, not to the panel law. 2 load-law tests fail and stay DISABLED_, each with its reason in 11.4 The default law's lift and angle form against the data (MARE-0110, MARE-0131); nothing is tuned to pass them.
Generated 2026-11-14 from commit d0d554b 2026-11-13 (with uncommitted changes under src/ or tests/); tests run 2026-11-14T10:52:31.010.
Tests
Status from the gtest XML of the last run. A DISABLED_ test fails against the current laws; its numbers are in the tables below, and it stays disabled until the owner decides the issue.
ENV-0125 (resolved), MARE-0110 (fhsim_marine_elements, resolved); none open
–
PanelLoadLaw_Rudi.WritesReport
PanelLoadLaw_Rudi_Test.cpp:43
passed
–
–
PanelLoadLaw Rudi report
tests/out/PanelLoadLaw_Rudi_report.txt, as the test wrote it.
PanelLoadLaw Rudi report (plan L5, MARE-0093). Rudi et al. 1988 via KF2012 Fig. 5.
Conventions: error = model/measured - 1 (in %) for loads and coefficients, model - measured for ratios and localCd; ratio = measured/model; margin = tolerance - |error| (negative = fails).
Readings: ratios normalised on the same net and speed, averaged over the speeds 0.159, 0.316, 0.966 m/s of the notes; nominal twine 1.0 mm, rho 1000, nu 1.0e-06 (they do not affect the ratios of LocalThroughFlow). Absolute errors.
L5 LocalThroughFlow with a3 = a5 = b4 = b6 = 0 (first harmonics only), C_D ratio (reported)
reported; 24 rows, 6 of 24 outside the tolerance.
Case
Measured
Model
Error
Tolerance
Margin
Result
Sn 0.130 CD( 0)/CD(0)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.130 CD(30)/CD(0)
0.845
0.866
0.021
±0.08
0.059
within
Sn 0.130 CD(45)/CD(0)
0.655
0.7071
0.052
±0.08
0.028
within
Sn 0.130 CD(60)/CD(0)
0.483
0.5
0.017
±0.08
0.063
within
Sn 0.130 CD(80)/CD(0)
0.276
0.1736
-0.102
±0.08
-0.022
outside
Sn 0.130 CD(90)/CD(0)
0
6.123e-17
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CD( 0)/CD(0)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CD(30)/CD(0)
0.778
0.866
0.088
±0.08
-0.008
outside
Sn 0.144 CD(45)/CD(0)
0.635
0.7071
0.072
±0.08
0.008
within
Sn 0.144 CD(60)/CD(0)
0.492
0.5
0.008
±0.08
0.072
within
Sn 0.144 CD(80)/CD(0)
0.238
0.1736
-0.064
±0.08
0.016
within
Sn 0.144 CD(90)/CD(0)
0.032
6.123e-17
-0.032
±0.08
0.048
within
Sn 0.184 CD( 0)/CD(0)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.184 CD(30)/CD(0)
0.736
0.866
0.13
±0.08
-0.05
outside
Sn 0.184 CD(45)/CD(0)
0.626
0.7071
0.081
±0.08
-0.001
outside
Sn 0.184 CD(60)/CD(0)
0.549
0.5
-0.049
±0.08
0.031
within
Sn 0.184 CD(80)/CD(0)
0.231
0.1736
-0.057
±0.08
0.023
within
Sn 0.184 CD(90)/CD(0)
0.011
6.123e-17
-0.011
±0.08
0.069
within
Sn 0.317 CD( 0)/CD(0)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.317 CD(30)/CD(0)
0.792
0.866
0.074
±0.08
0.006
within
Sn 0.317 CD(45)/CD(0)
0.575
0.7071
0.132
±0.08
-0.052
outside
Sn 0.317 CD(60)/CD(0)
0.389
0.5
0.111
±0.08
-0.031
outside
Sn 0.317 CD(80)/CD(0)
0.131
0.1736
0.043
±0.08
0.037
within
Sn 0.317 CD(90)/CD(0)
0.023
6.123e-17
-0.023
±0.08
0.057
within
L5 LocalThroughFlow with a3 = a5 = b4 = b6 = 0 (first harmonics only), C_L ratio (reported)
reported; 24 rows, 7 of 24 outside the tolerance.
Case
Measured
Model
Error
Tolerance
Margin
Result
Sn 0.130 CL( 0)/CL(45)
0
0
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.130 CL(30)/CL(45)
1
0.866
-0.134
±0.08
-0.054
outside
Sn 0.130 CL(45)/CL(45)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.130 CL(60)/CL(45)
0.909
0.866
-0.043
±0.08
0.037
within
Sn 0.130 CL(80)/CL(45)
0.455
0.342
-0.113
±0.08
-0.033
outside
Sn 0.130 CL(90)/CL(45)
0
1.225e-16
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CL( 0)/CL(45)
0
0
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CL(30)/CL(45)
1.091
0.866
-0.225
±0.08
-0.145
outside
Sn 0.144 CL(45)/CL(45)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CL(60)/CL(45)
0.909
0.866
-0.043
±0.08
0.037
within
Sn 0.144 CL(80)/CL(45)
0.636
0.342
-0.294
±0.08
-0.214
outside
Sn 0.144 CL(90)/CL(45)
0
1.225e-16
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.184 CL( 0)/CL(45)
0
0
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.184 CL(30)/CL(45)
1
0.866
-0.134
±0.08
-0.054
outside
Sn 0.184 CL(45)/CL(45)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.184 CL(60)/CL(45)
0.8
0.866
0.066
±0.08
0.014
within
Sn 0.184 CL(80)/CL(45)
0.35
0.342
-0.008
±0.08
0.072
within
Sn 0.184 CL(90)/CL(45)
0
1.225e-16
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.317 CL( 0)/CL(45)
0
0
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.317 CL(30)/CL(45)
1.019
0.866
-0.153
±0.08
-0.073
outside
Sn 0.317 CL(45)/CL(45)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.317 CL(60)/CL(45)
0.769
0.866
0.097
±0.08
-0.017
outside
Sn 0.317 CL(80)/CL(45)
0.308
0.342
0.034
±0.08
0.046
within
Sn 0.317 CL(90)/CL(45)
0
1.225e-16
0
±0.08
0.08
within
L5 ScreenMF2022 (a3 fitted per Sn, b4 0; Sn 0.130/0.144 outside Eq. 10 range), C_D ratio (reported)
reported; 24 rows, 8 of 24 outside the tolerance.
Case
Measured
Model
Error
Tolerance
Margin
Result
Sn 0.130 CD( 0)/CD(0)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.130 CD(30)/CD(0)
0.845
0.7514
-0.094
±0.08
-0.014
outside
Sn 0.130 CD(45)/CD(0)
0.655
0.52
-0.135
±0.08
-0.055
outside
Sn 0.130 CD(60)/CD(0)
0.483
0.3015
-0.181
±0.08
-0.101
outside
Sn 0.130 CD(80)/CD(0)
0.276
0.08451
-0.191
±0.08
-0.111
outside
Sn 0.130 CD(90)/CD(0)
0
2.882e-17
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CD( 0)/CD(0)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CD(30)/CD(0)
0.778
0.7742
-0.004
±0.08
0.076
within
Sn 0.144 CD(45)/CD(0)
0.635
0.5571
-0.078
±0.08
0.002
within
Sn 0.144 CD(60)/CD(0)
0.492
0.3409
-0.151
±0.08
-0.071
outside
Sn 0.144 CD(80)/CD(0)
0.238
0.1022
-0.136
±0.08
-0.056
outside
Sn 0.144 CD(90)/CD(0)
0.032
3.526e-17
-0.032
±0.08
0.048
within
Sn 0.184 CD( 0)/CD(0)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.184 CD(30)/CD(0)
0.736
0.8046
0.069
±0.08
0.011
within
Sn 0.184 CD(45)/CD(0)
0.626
0.6068
-0.019
±0.08
0.061
within
Sn 0.184 CD(60)/CD(0)
0.549
0.3936
-0.155
±0.08
-0.075
outside
Sn 0.184 CD(80)/CD(0)
0.231
0.1259
-0.105
±0.08
-0.025
outside
Sn 0.184 CD(90)/CD(0)
0.011
4.386e-17
-0.011
±0.08
0.069
within
Sn 0.317 CD( 0)/CD(0)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.317 CD(30)/CD(0)
0.792
0.8014
0.009
±0.08
0.071
within
Sn 0.317 CD(45)/CD(0)
0.575
0.6016
0.027
±0.08
0.053
within
Sn 0.317 CD(60)/CD(0)
0.389
0.3881
-0.001
±0.08
0.079
within
Sn 0.317 CD(80)/CD(0)
0.131
0.1234
-0.008
±0.08
0.072
within
Sn 0.317 CD(90)/CD(0)
0.023
4.295e-17
-0.023
±0.08
0.057
within
L5 ScreenMF2022, C_L ratio (reported)
reported; 24 rows, 7 of 24 outside the tolerance.
Case
Measured
Model
Error
Tolerance
Margin
Result
Sn 0.130 CL( 0)/CL(45)
0
0
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.130 CL(30)/CL(45)
1
0.866
-0.134
±0.08
-0.054
outside
Sn 0.130 CL(45)/CL(45)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.130 CL(60)/CL(45)
0.909
0.866
-0.043
±0.08
0.037
within
Sn 0.130 CL(80)/CL(45)
0.455
0.342
-0.113
±0.08
-0.033
outside
Sn 0.130 CL(90)/CL(45)
0
1.225e-16
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CL( 0)/CL(45)
0
0
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CL(30)/CL(45)
1.091
0.866
-0.225
±0.08
-0.145
outside
Sn 0.144 CL(45)/CL(45)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.144 CL(60)/CL(45)
0.909
0.866
-0.043
±0.08
0.037
within
Sn 0.144 CL(80)/CL(45)
0.636
0.342
-0.294
±0.08
-0.214
outside
Sn 0.144 CL(90)/CL(45)
0
1.225e-16
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.184 CL( 0)/CL(45)
0
0
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.184 CL(30)/CL(45)
1
0.866
-0.134
±0.08
-0.054
outside
Sn 0.184 CL(45)/CL(45)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.184 CL(60)/CL(45)
0.8
0.866
0.066
±0.08
0.014
within
Sn 0.184 CL(80)/CL(45)
0.35
0.342
-0.008
±0.08
0.072
within
Sn 0.184 CL(90)/CL(45)
0
1.225e-16
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.317 CL( 0)/CL(45)
0
0
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.317 CL(30)/CL(45)
1.019
0.866
-0.153
±0.08
-0.073
outside
Sn 0.317 CL(45)/CL(45)
1
1
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Sn 0.317 CL(60)/CL(45)
0.769
0.866
0.097
±0.08
-0.017
outside
Sn 0.317 CL(80)/CL(45)
0.308
0.342
0.034
±0.08
0.046
within
Sn 0.317 CL(90)/CL(45)
0
1.225e-16
0
±0.08
0.08
within
Data provenance
Every measured number in the tables above comes from these files (contract C6); the header of each gives the paper, the table or figure, how it was obtained and its uncertainty.
Rudi H, Loland G, Furunes I (1988), Modellforsok med noter. Krefter og gjennomstromning pa enkeltpaneler og merdsystemer, SINTEF report (in Norwegian); available only via Kristiansen T, Faltinsen OM (2012), Modelling of current loads on aquaculture net cages, J. Fluids Struct. 34, 218-235 (KF2012)
location
KF2012 Fig. 5 (journal p. 224, PDF p. 7)
kind
digitised
uncertainty
+-0.005 (marker centres read from the PDF vector drawing, axes calibrated on the tick marks; not eye-read)
units
sn [-], theta_deg [deg], cd_over_cd0 [-], cl_over_cl45 [-]
notes
Rudi 1988 itself is not in background/; these values are KF2012's plot of it. The report is dated 1988 in KF2012 and 1989 in MF2022 ref. [7].
notes
Flat 1.5 x 1.5 m panels on a stiff frame, angles 0-90 deg; each value is the average over the three towing speeds 0.159, 0.316 and 0.966 m/s (KF2012 p. 224). Drag normalised by its theta = 0 value, lift by its theta = 45 deg value. The Sn = 0.243 net deformed strongly and is not plotted by KF2012.
notes
The Sn = 0.144 triangle markers sit 0.004 above their data point in the drawing (their bounding-box centre reads 1.004 at both normalisation points and 0.004 at the lift zeros); 0.004 is subtracted from every 0.144 value.
notes
Where two nets share a position the markers coincide in the drawing (e.g. all four at cd_over_cd0 = 1 at 0 deg). The 1.000 values at the normalisation angles are read from the figure, not set.