FhSim  3.1.0
Marine systems simulation
Loading...
Searching...
No Matches
0161 — NormalDragCoefficient: 14 to 32 % above Wieselsberger at low Re, 6 to 7 % below on the plateau (A3)
ID 0161
Class KNOWN-LIMITATION
Severity 1
Status blocked

Models: — (annotated on the fhsim_environment library group)

Found: 2026-11-18, plan HP wave 2

Decision needed: the owner chooses whether to verify the source of the low-Re branch (White, Viscous Fluid Flow, quoted from memory) or to accept the fit.

Evidence

include/fhsim_environment/hydrodynamics/CylinderHydro.h:79-82: the comment says the equation number and range of the low-Re branch are cited from memory and the reference is to verify. The branch is Cd = 1 + 10 Re^(-2/3) below kLowReynolds (line 48).

Case A3 of fhsim_validation (cases/hydrodynamics/cylinder_load/A3_cylinder_cd_re, tracked):

  • At Re 4 to 18 (4 rows) the fit is 14 to 32 % above Wieselsberger 1921.
  • On the plateau, Re 5e3 to 2e5, the fit gives 1.08 to 1.14 against 1.2 of Wieselsberger (-6 to -7 %). Schewe 1983, corrected for blockage, agrees within 5 %.

Effect

Drag of thin cylinders at Re below 20 is too high. On the plateau the drag is 6 to 7 % low against Wieselsberger and within 5 % of Schewe.

Possible fix

  • Verify the source of the low-Re branch and fix the equation, range or reference.
  • Or accept the fit and record the distance in the validation report.

Test that would prove it

The A3 rows at Re 4 to 18 pass their bands (ctest -R fhsim_validation_laws, case A3).

Risk

Any change of NormalDragCoefficient moves every cable and cylinder result (base, ME, fishery, maritime). Report the moves in the moves.md of those repos.