FhSim  3.1.0
Marine systems simulation
Loading...
Searching...
No Matches
0157 — Default panel law drag about 21 % low for clean nets at 0.1 m/s (Gansel 2015)
ID 0157
Class KNOWN-LIMITATION
Severity 2
Status blocked

Models: — (annotated on the fhsim_environment library group)

Found: 2026-11-18, validation case B8 (fhsim_validation, cases/hydrodynamics/net_panel_load/B8_gansel_cd)

Decision needed: the owner chooses whether the default panel law should match Gansel et al. 2015 at low twine Re and high solidity, or whether case B8 documents a model range limit.

Evidence

Case B8 (tracked, per-row tolerance 5 to 13 %) compares the drag coefficient of clean nets with Gansel et al. 2015 (PLOS ONE, Fig 5): solidity Sn 0.18 to 0.43, U 0.1 m/s, theta 0, 11 rows. The twine diameters in fhsim_validation/sources/gansel2015/fig5.csv are 1.3 to 2.9 mm, so twine Re = U d / nu is about 130 to 290. Reference run (fhsim_validation/results/reference/validation_results_laws_tracked.json):

law rows passing median error min max
LocalThroughFlow 2 of 11 -0.209 -0.251 -0.028
ScreenKF2012 2 of 11 +0.059 -0.163 +0.285
ScreenMF2022 0 of 11 -0.386

The laws are in fhsim_environment/include/fhsim_environment/hydrodynamics/ (LocalThroughFlow.h, ScreenKF2012.h, ScreenMF2022.h).

Effect

For clean nets at 0.1 m/s the default law gives about 21 % too little drag. The cause is not verified in code. This Re is below the range of most fits, which may be a reason.

Possible fix

  1. Find the cause in the laws (low-Re twine drag or solidity effect) and change the law.
  2. Keep the laws and state the Re and solidity range in the documentation and in case B8.

Test that would prove it

Case B8: all 11 rows pass for the default law.

Risk

Changing the default law moves the drag of every net, so regression baselines move and need an owner ruling.